Get Tickets

Uncovering the Forgotten Fowl

Evolutionary Adaptations of Ancestral Ducks in Hawaiʻi
Larger Bodies, Larger Eggs

Hawaiian birds evolved unique adaptations due to the Islands’ isolation, diverse food sources, and lack of mammalian predators. Fossil discoveries have provided crucial insights into long-extinct species, revealing details about their physical characteristics and lifestyles. Modern techniques, including 3D scanning and printing, are used to reconstruct extinct species, aiding in the study and preservation of Hawaiʻi’s avian history.

A long metallic and mesh fence running along a dirt path with lush greenery on both sides, under a clear blue sky with a view of water in the distance.
Three hikers with backpacks walk along a fenced trail up a green, tree-lined hill under a clear blue sky.

Images: Predator-proof fences on Hawaii’s isolated islands are vital for conserving native wildlife. These barriers, as seen in the steep terrain of Kauaʻi and other islands, prevent invasive species such as rats, cats, and mongoose from entering and disrupting the delicate ecosystems. By creating safe havens for native plants and animals, these fences play a crucial role in maintaining the unique biodiversity of Hawaii, which has evolved in isolation over millions of years. Conservation efforts like these are essential for preserving Hawaii’s natural heritage.

Uncovering the Forgotten Fowl

Immediate Takeaways

Unique Adaptations.

Birds that arrived in Hawaiʻi sometimes underwent drastic changes as they adapted to their new home.

The Fossil Record.

Studies of moanalo fossils indicate that they may have adapted their digestive system to eat more fibrous vegetation than the small ducks from which they evolved.

Ecological Roles.

Since ungulates, like sheep and goats, weren’t able to establish themselves in Hawaiʻi, the moanalo may have been the main herbivores in the Islands for hundreds of thousands of years.

Modern Reconstruction.

3D scanning and printing technologies are being used to reconstruct extinct Hawaiian birds, enhancing our understanding and conservation efforts.
Helen James is a research zoologist and curator of birds at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History. She has worked since the 1970’s to collect Hawaiian fossil birds in conjunction with Bishop Museum, where she is a research affiliate. In this video, she discusses how she and her collaborators came up with the name “moanalo”.
Helen James, research zoologist and curator of birds at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History, discusses which characteristics reveal that an extinct species of bird was flightless.

Evolutionary Adaptations of Ancestral Ducks in Hawaiʻi

When ancestral ducks arrived in Hawaiʻi millions of years ago, they encountered a unique environment with abundant food resources and a lack of mammalian predators. Fewer predators meant more freedom to explore new ecological niches. Without sharp-toothed predators lurking about, the ducks weren’t restricted to wetland habitats, which offer some safety from non-aquatic animals looking for an easy meal.

Slowly, the ducks that arrived in Hawaiʻi made their way into the forests and began eating a very different diet. The plants they encountered contained much more fiber than the soft, aquatic vegetation they ate normally. The increase in fiber may have encouraged a shift in how these birds digested their food. More specifically, it may have encouraged a shift toward hindgut fermentation, a digestive process that is common among herbivorous mammals, but generally rare in the avian world.

Hindgut fermentation, a process where microbial digestion occurs after food has exited the small intestine, is rare among birds primarily because their digestive systems are highly specialized for efficient nutrient extraction and flight. Most birds have a relatively short digestive tract that prioritizes quick digestion and absorption of nutrients, which is crucial for their high metabolic rates and energy demands during flight. Additionally, most birds lack enlarged caeca, a pair of pouches between the small and large intestines where fermentation occurs.

Geese and other waterfowl like swans can perform hindgut fermentation to some extent. They have well-developed caeca, which are essential for housing the symbiotic microbes necessary for hindgut fermentation. This allows them to break down complex plant materials, such as tough grasses and sedges. The fermentation process extracts additional nutrients from their fibrous diet, making it an important adaptation for these herbivorous birds.

Some species of ducks also have the capacity for hindgut fermentation when conditions, like harsh winter weather, require them to eat more fiber. Over a matter of weeks, mallards can enlarge their colon, liver, and caeca, allowing fermentative digestion. The ancestral ducks that gave rise to the moanalo may have had a similar ability when they arrived in Hawaiʻi and began invading woodland habitats.

Person carefully holding and examining a small bone wrapped in tissue paper during an archaeological excavation.
Excavation
Thambetochen xanion
Oʻahu moanalo (Thambetochen xanion) leg bone found at a fossil site on the windward coast of Oʻahu.

Photo: Molly Hagemann
Excavation
Researchers on a rocky shore are setting up equipment and supplies for a field study. One person is pointing toward the distance, while others are organizing items near containers.
Fossil Collection
Collecting Fossils
Helen James (in purple shirt) with Bishop Museum staff and volunteers collecting fossils at a site on the windward coast of Oʻahu.

Photo: Warren Johnson
Fossil Collection
Illustration of seven geese aligned side by side, varying in size and color, ranging from dark brown to light tan to reddish and white.
Comparisons
Moanalo and Geese Evolution
A comparison of the moanalo and geese that evolved in the Hawaiian Islands. From left to right: giant goose (Branta rhuax), turtle-jawed moanalo (Chelychelynechen quassus), dryland moanalo (Thambetochen chauliodus), Oʻahu moanalo (Thambetochen xanion), stumbling moanalo (Ptaiochen pau), woods-walking goose (Branta hylobadistes), nēnē (Branta sandvicensis). All are extinct except the nēnē.

Painting: Julian Hume
Comparisons
Painting of two large, brown birds with white heads standing near an egg on the ground, surrounded by lush, green foliage.
Stumbling Moanalo
Ptaiochen pau
Julian Hume’s painting of the stumbling moanalo (Ptaiochen pau).
Stumbling Moanalo
Person carefully holding and examining a small bone wrapped in tissue paper during an archaeological excavation.
Thambetochen xanion
Oʻahu moanalo (Thambetochen xanion) leg bone found at a fossil site on the windward coast of Oʻahu.

Photo: Molly Hagemann
Researchers on a rocky shore are setting up equipment and supplies for a field study. One person is pointing toward the distance, while others are organizing items near containers.
Collecting Fossils
Helen James (in purple shirt) with Bishop Museum staff and volunteers collecting fossils at a site on the windward coast of Oʻahu.

Photo: Warren Johnson
Illustration of seven geese aligned side by side, varying in size and color, ranging from dark brown to light tan to reddish and white.
Moanalo and Geese Evolution
A comparison of the moanalo and geese that evolved in the Hawaiian Islands. From left to right: giant goose (Branta rhuax), turtle-jawed moanalo (Chelychelynechen quassus), dryland moanalo (Thambetochen chauliodus), Oʻahu moanalo (Thambetochen xanion), stumbling moanalo (Ptaiochen pau), woods-walking goose (Branta hylobadistes), nēnē (Branta sandvicensis). All are extinct except the nēnē.

Painting: Julian Hume
Painting of two large, brown birds with white heads standing near an egg on the ground, surrounded by lush, green foliage.
Ptaiochen pau
Julian Hume’s painting of the stumbling moanalo (Ptaiochen pau).
Excavation
Fossil Collection
Comparisons
Stumbling Moanalo

Larger Bodies, Larger Eggs

Fermentation requires heat, which is easier to maintain with a larger body size. And it’s easier to maintain a larger body if you don’t need to lift that body off the ground. So, the shift to hindgut fermentation and the loss of flight may have gone hand -in -hand. Similar influences may have also led to a shift from laying multiple, smaller eggs to investing resources in one large egg.

Bird species that lay large clutches of eggs typically do so as an adaptation to unpredictable conditions. By laying multiple eggs, these species increase the likelihood that at least some offspring will survive to adulthood despite predation, environmental challenges, or other risks.

If conditions were more predictable, with fewer predators and habitats that no longer required migration to seasonal wetlands, then the ducks in Hawaiʻi would have a good chance at reproductive success, even if there’’s only one egg in their proverbial basket. Success may be more likely still if the chick in that egg is big. Chicks that can ferment their meals as early as possible would have an advantage over ones that must wait until they grow large enough to maintain the necessary high body temperature.

By analyzing the curvature of fossil eggshell fragments collected in a dry lava tube cave on Maui, researchers have extrapolated the overall size and shape of a stumbling moanalo (Ptaiochen pau) egg. The egg in the Lele o Nā Manu exhibit was 3D-printed using a digital reconstruction based on those fragments.

Julian Hume, artist and paleontologist, reconstructs a stumbling moanalo (Ptaiochen pau) skeleton. The bones he’s using were 3D printed from scans taken of actual fossil bones collected on Maui.

Final Takeaways

Evolutionary Adaptation.

Hawaiian birds like the moanalo evolved unique adaptations, such as hindgut fermentation, in response to the islands’ predator-free environments and abundant food resources.

Fossil Discoveries.

Extensive fossil records, including leg bones and eggshell fragments, have provided critical insights into the physical characteristics and lifestyles of extinct Hawaiian bird species.

Importance of Body Size.

The evolution of larger body sizes in Hawaiian birds facilitated the maintenance of necessary heat for fermentation and contributed to their ability to lay larger, fewer eggs, enhancing chick survival rates.

Conservation and Reconstruction Efforts.

Modern techniques like 3D scanning and printing have enabled the reconstruction of extinct species like the stumbling moanalo, aiding in the study and preservation of Hawaiian avian history.
Skip to content